Thomas Tallis School
  • Home
  • About
    • An Overview >
      • The Leadership Team
      • Who was Thomas Tallis?
      • Ethos and Values
      • School Vision
      • Artsmark
      • International School
      • Ofsted
    • School Prospectus
    • Mrs Roberts Writes
    • Tallis Habits >
      • Tallis Pedagogy Wheel Guide
    • Tallis Character
    • Tate Exchange
    • Secondary School Direct Hub
    • The Pupil Premium 2018-19 >
      • The Pupil Premium 2017-18
      • The Pupil Premium 2016-17
      • The Pupil Premium 2015-16
      • The Pupil Premium 2014-15
      • The Pupil Premium 2013-14
      • The Pupil Premium 2012-13
      • The Pupil Premium 2011-12
    • Exam Results 2018 >
      • Exam Results 2017
      • Exam Results 2016
      • Exam Results 2015
      • Exam Results 2014
      • Exam Results 2013
      • Exam Results 2012
      • Exam Results 2011
    • Early Catch Up 2017/2018 and Action Plan 2018/19 >
      • Early catch-up review and action plan 2017-18
    • Job Vacancies
  • News
    • Tallis Newsletters
    • BBC School Report 2018
    • Tallis Photography
    • Tallis Video
    • Tallis Sounds
  • Calendar
    • The School Day
    • Term Dates 2018-19
  • Curriculum
    • Curriculum Areas >
      • Business & ICT
      • Computing
      • English & Philosophy
      • Design & Technology
      • Humanities & Social Sciences
      • Mathematics
      • Modern Foreign Languages
      • Performing Arts
      • Physical Education
      • Science
      • Visual & Media Arts
    • Pastoral Care
    • Guidance
    • Key Stage 3 >
      • KS3 Assessment guidance
      • Tallis Choices
    • Key Stage 4
    • Tallis Post 16
    • More Able Learners
    • Special Educational Needs & Disabilities >
      • Learning Support Unit
      • Support Centre for Autism and Language Impairment
      • Deaf Support Centre
      • English as an Additional Language
    • Extra-Curricular Activities
  • Community
    • Letters Home
    • PTFA >
      • Supporting Thomas Tallis School
    • Governing Board
    • The Tallis Agreement
    • Admissions
    • Transition
    • Attendance & Punctuality
    • School Uniform
    • Policies & Guidelines >
      • Making Complaints
    • Support Your Teen
    • Online Safety
    • WisePay Payment Portal
    • Tallis Post 16
  • Students
    • Year 11 Support & Guidance
    • Independent Learning
    • Exam Revision
    • Stay Safe
    • Rewards
    • Reading
    • The Library
    • School Council
    • Cycling at Tallis
    • Alumni
  • Staff
  • Links
  • Contact
    • School Map
    • How to find us
  • Search
T: +44 (0)208 856 0115

EDUCATION TO UNDERSTAND THE WORLD & CHANGE IT FOR THE BETTER

Arrested on a train

5/10/2018

1 Comment

 
Picture
I was minding my own business on the jolly old Southeastern into London Bridge when my attention was arrested by a poster advertising a grammar school served by the same locomotive. It asked rather loudly, ‘HAVE YOU JUST BEEN DEEMED SELECTIVE BY BEXLEY’S 11+ TEST?’

Immune to the concerns of other passengers I approached and photographed this shameless assault on language and then asked everyone on the mothership what it meant. I don’t allow that kind of talk at Tallis so no one knew.  Consulting the ether, apparently, ‘deemed selective’ is the status a child attains who has passed the 11+. Charming.   
I’m trying to keep up with the reading so I’ve already told you about Robert Verkaik and Melissa Benn this year. Now I’m going to tell you about another bonza tome, Miseducation : inequality, education and the working classes by Cambridge and LSE Emeritus Professor Diane Reay. Brought up on the Derbyshire coalfield, she taught in London primary schools for 20 years, so she knows a thing or two. It’s very readable.

Her first chapter, Why can’t education compensate for society? sets out her thesis. Both class and poverty have always distanced working class children from education, but recent fads and interventions have made this worse, not better.   

Focusing on test scores as a measure of school quality has a particularly dangerous effect on schools which serve largely poor communities. Those pressures – and their leaders’ choices - lead to narrowed curriculums and obsessive teaching-to-the-test largely unknown by more advantaged children whose teachers are more confident about results.   

Schools serving poorer communities have a majority of young and inexperienced teachers, committed and determined but rarely from similar backgrounds to the children. They may have been skimpily trained on programmes which stress the adoption of particular practices (fancy uniform, zero tolerance) said to be modelled on the public schools, but which rarely exist there.

Schools justify these hideous proxies because they say they need to re-shape children’s character and outlook in order for them to succeed. Some go further, saying that children from ‘chaotic’ homes need order and structure in school to be able to free themselves from the lives their parents lead. Some – fee-paying as well as and normal schools – equate parental worth with cars and holidays, a ‘nice house’.    
   
In this way, loose talk about social mobility becomes a frontal assault on the parenting of those trapped in poverty. ‘This education will give you a good life, better than your parents’. Ergo, your parents are deficient, shameful, they have let you down. Reay uses a clear phrase here, describing ‘shame as the darker side of optimism’. Optimism is expected in school, or at least its functional twin, aspiration. Optimism is natural to young people despite teenage gloom. Aspiration is more specific, always linked to hard work, good exam results and university entry. In this way, social mobility is outsourced to the child: if he isn’t sufficiently aspirational he throws away his chance of escaping poverty. It’s his fault.  

In a chapter called Class Feeling: troubling the soul and preying on the psyche’ Reay quotes from extensive interviews with children in primary schools where they define themselves by their grades, where they ‘know’ that they’ll have a ‘bad life’ if they get a ‘bad score’. This focus on grades above all, she says, has ‘shifted children’s self-identification as learners’. They are their grades, not their efforts and their insights. If grades are bad, they must be bad, and unworthy of escaping poverty.

While advantaged children also suffer from soul-destroying commodification by potential exam results, they do not have to engage in ‘rational computation’ in order to meet the goals that best suit their interests. If you ‘know’ that you will go to Oxford (Cambridge, St Andrew’s, Durham, Imperial or wherever) because that’s where people like you always go, you don’t have to think much about it. Everything about your life has readied you to get in. You are fine being yourself, you don’t have to learn to become someone else. Oh, and personal private tutoring is built into the family budget. 

So, not only do many poor children go to schools where the teacher shortage really bites, but some of the newly-popular ways of running schools are deliberately framed as places where children have to disown their parents.  From a position of poverty (30% of all children now), they are expected to value material success as an output of education which, if they fail, is their fault for not aiming high enough. While current policy claims to try to raise working-class achievement, by its approach and funding it actually ensures that failure is firmly located in the working class.  If you remain working class like your parents, you are a failure.  What kind of madness is this?
Uninformed madness. 'A plethora of spectacular educational irrelevancies such as standards, testing regimes, raising attainment and achievement levels, league tables, school choice, academies and charter schools, performativities and managerialism, image and impression management, academic/vocational streaming, punitive naming and shaming strategies and the rhetoric of school improvement and school effectiveness have obscured the crucial importance of social class to educational success.’

What does work? Reay says: collaboration rather than setting and streaming. Intense personal learning relationships between teacher and child that empower students as ‘knowers’. Passionate engagement, original thought. And perhaps working towards an answer to the question ‘why English education has never embraced approaches that work and adopts those that don’t?’ Grammar schools, anyone?  Why bother with the 11+ test? The evidence shows that the ‘deemed selective’ child was actually selected much earlier.

Anyway, the reason I was on the train to start with was to go on the Worth Less? school funding march. We were, as the organisers said, ‘relentlessly reasonable’ and have carried on being so this week as the sheer effrontery of the DFE claim about funding has been systematically unpicked and exposed as shameless falsehood. The UK Statistics Authority is calling it in for investigation, so all power to their spreadsheets and swivel chairs (which is how I picture them).  

I was directing traffic and some year 8 boys passed me. One said to the other ‘I’m praying for something good to come out of it’.  Who knows what that problem was, but Amen to that.
 
CR
4.10.18
1 Comment
mum
5/11/2018 01:05:41 pm

When my child was in Year 6 I thought I would go mad from hype of selective schools.

My husband and I are expats, which means we grew up in another country where local children go to local schools until they are 18 years old. This doesn't mean that 'back home', the education system is without challenges or issues, but selective schools and the cost and obsession is new to us.

We do our best to raise our kids, and want them to value what it means to be a good person in our world. We felt strongly felt that 'sitting the 11+' would not be the right choice for our kids. The age was not the right time to define and be a 'success', but enjoy childhood and slowly learn to have self belief in what you want to do, not what systems tell you 'success' means.

We did feel disheartened when our local secondary was deemed 'inadequate' across the board by Ofstead. The stress from this meant that I avoided the school gates for the final year of primary school, which was sad to say.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    MRS ROBERTS WRITES...

    A regular column about school life.

    Archive

    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013

    Categories

    All
    11+
    1970s
    Academies
    Academisation
    Accountability
    Achievement
    Administrators
    Admissions
    Adolescence
    Adulthood
    Adventure
    Adverts
    Advice
    Aleppo
    Alevels
    Ambassador
    Annefrank
    Anthonyhorowitz
    Apologies
    Arabic
    Aristotle
    Art
    Arts
    Artsmark
    Ascl
    Askforangela
    Aspiration
    Assemblies
    Assembly
    Assessment
    Assessments
    Attendance
    Autonomy
    Banding
    Battle
    Battleaxes
    Bbc
    Beginnings
    Behaviour
    Belonging
    Berylhusain
    Beveridge
    Billlucas
    Blogosphere
    Boundaries
    Bowie
    Brexit
    Brext
    Briefing
    Bruisers
    Bsf
    Btec
    Budget
    Budgets
    Bugsy
    Building
    Bureaucracy
    Cameron
    Campaign
    Capital
    Catalytic
    Celebration
    Ceremonies
    Ceremony
    Certificates
    Champions
    Change
    Changes
    Character
    Charity
    Charlescausley
    Childhood
    Children
    Choices
    Christmas
    Cicero
    Citizenship
    Civic
    Civility
    Classrooms
    Clothes
    Code
    Cohesion
    Colleagues
    Commission
    Commodification
    Community
    Compassion
    Compliance
    Comprehensive
    Compromise
    Conference
    Confucius
    Conservative
    Context
    Continuity
    Controversy
    Conversation
    Corridors
    Cover
    Craft
    Creativity
    Cressidadick
    Crime
    Cslewis
    Culture
    Curriculum
    Cuts
    Cyberspace
    Dance
    Darkness
    Data
    Davidharsent
    Deadlines
    Decisions
    Deliverology
    Democracy
    Deregulation
    Design
    Detention
    Determination
    Dfe
    Dianereay
    Diligence
    Disadvantage
    Discipline
    Discussion
    Drama
    D&t
    Durham
    Easter
    Ebacc
    Eclipse
    Economy
    Edhirsch
    Education
    Eglantynejebb
    Election
    Elite
    Empathy
    Empowerment
    Engagement
    Entitlement
    Epiphany
    Equality
    Equipment
    Ethics
    Eton
    Events
    Everyday
    Exams
    Excellence
    Exchange
    Exclusions
    Expectations
    Experience
    Explosions
    Extremism
    Facilities
    Fairness
    Faith
    Fame
    Family
    Fashion
    Festival
    Fidelity
    Finances
    Fitness
    Food
    Football
    Freedom
    Freeschool
    Friends
    Friendship
    Functionalism
    Funding
    Future
    Gcse
    Gcses
    Generosity
    Geography
    German
    Germans
    Gestures
    Girls
    Gove
    Government
    Governors
    Grammar
    Greenwich
    Grenfell
    Habits
    Happiness
    Headstart
    Hippocrates
    History
    Hmci
    Hmi
    Holidays
    Holocaust
    Homelessness
    Homework
    Hugging
    Humanity
    Humanutopia
    Hunger
    Hymnsheets
    Ict
    Illumination
    Imagination
    Immigrants
    Inclusion
    Information
    Injustice
    Inspection
    Institution
    Integrity
    Interdependence
    International
    Interpretation
    Interviews
    Investment
    Invigilation
    Invigilators
    IPad
    Islam
    Johnrawls
    Journeys
    Joy
    Judgement
    Justice
    Kaospilots
    Kidbrooke
    Kindness
    Knowledge
    Ks3
    Languages
    Laughter
    Leadership
    Learners
    Learning
    Leaving
    Lessons
    Levels
    List
    Literacy
    Literature
    London
    Londonchallenge
    Love
    Luck
    Lunchtime
    Management
    Mandarin
    Mandela
    Marland
    Mastery
    Maths
    Mats
    May
    Memories
    Menstruation
    Metrics
    Michaelyoung
    Misconduct
    Miseducation
    Mistakes
    Mobility
    Mocks
    Money
    Mothers
    Motto
    Multiculturalism
    Music
    Musical
    Myths
    Nationality
    Neo-trad
    News
    Newyear
    Nhs
    Nickymorgan
    Nihilism
    Nolan
    Nqt
    NSPCC
    Nuremburg
    Oaa
    Oath
    Obama
    Objectivity
    Oecd
    Offence
    Ofsted
    Ombusdman
    Openevening
    Openness
    Optimism
    Outcomes
    Oxbridge
    Parenting
    Parents
    Participation
    Partnership
    Pastoral
    Pay
    PE
    Peace
    Pedagogy
    People
    Performance
    Persistent
    Pfi
    Philosophy
    Photography
    Pisa
    Planning
    Plumbing
    Poetry
    Policy
    Politeness
    Politicians
    Politics
    Posh
    Post16
    Postmodernism
    Poverty
    Powerpoint
    Practice
    Praxis
    Predictions
    Preparations
    Pressures
    Prevent
    Principles
    Priorities
    Private
    Privilege
    Procedures
    Progress
    Progress8
    Proxy
    Pta
    Public
    Publicservices
    Punctuality
    Punctuation
    Punishment
    Pupilpremium
    Qualifications
    Questioning
    Questions
    Raf
    R&d
    RE
    Reading
    Recruitment
    Refugees
    Regulations
    Relationships
    Religion
    Remembrance
    Reports
    Research
    Resilience
    Resits
    Resolutions
    Resources
    Respect
    Responsibilities
    Restorativejustice
    Results
    Retention
    Revision
    Rewards
    Rhetoric
    Rules
    Safeguarding
    Sarcasm
    Savethechildren
    Scandal
    Scholarship
    School
    Schools
    Schoolsweek
    Science
    Selection
    Selflessness
    September
    Service
    Sex
    Sexism
    Shakespeare
    Shortage
    Sixthform
    Socialmedia
    Society
    Speech
    Speeches
    Sports
    Staffing
    Staffroom
    Standardisation
    Standards
    State
    Study
    Suffering
    Summer
    Syria
    System
    Taiwan
    Talk
    Targets
    Tate
    Teacherly
    Teachers
    Teachfirst
    Teaching
    Technology
    Teenagers
    Terrorism
    Tests
    Textbooks
    Thinking
    Thomastallis
    Time
    Timetable
    Toilets
    Traceyemin
    Tradition
    Transgender
    Transition
    Trump
    Truth
    Ttra
    Tutor
    Twitter
    Ucas
    Understanding
    Uniform
    Unitednations
    University
    Values
    Veilofignorance
    Victorian
    Violence
    Virtues
    Visitors
    Visits
    Walkabout
    War
    Warmth
    Weather
    Welcome
    Westminster
    Whatwouldyoucut
    Whistleblowing
    Whistles
    Whitepaper
    Wilshaw
    Winter
    Wisdom
    Women
    Workload
    Worth
    Writing
    WW1
    Year
    Year13
    Year6
    Year7
    Year9
    Yoga
    Youth
    Zeitgeist

    RSS Feed

Thomas Tallis School, Kidbrooke Park Road, London SE3 9PX
T: +44 (0)208 856 0115   F: +44 (0)208 331 3004   E: headteacher@thomastallis.org.uk
  • Home
  • About
    • An Overview >
      • The Leadership Team
      • Who was Thomas Tallis?
      • Ethos and Values
      • School Vision
      • Artsmark
      • International School
      • Ofsted
    • School Prospectus
    • Mrs Roberts Writes
    • Tallis Habits >
      • Tallis Pedagogy Wheel Guide
    • Tallis Character
    • Tate Exchange
    • Secondary School Direct Hub
    • The Pupil Premium 2018-19 >
      • The Pupil Premium 2017-18
      • The Pupil Premium 2016-17
      • The Pupil Premium 2015-16
      • The Pupil Premium 2014-15
      • The Pupil Premium 2013-14
      • The Pupil Premium 2012-13
      • The Pupil Premium 2011-12
    • Exam Results 2018 >
      • Exam Results 2017
      • Exam Results 2016
      • Exam Results 2015
      • Exam Results 2014
      • Exam Results 2013
      • Exam Results 2012
      • Exam Results 2011
    • Early Catch Up 2017/2018 and Action Plan 2018/19 >
      • Early catch-up review and action plan 2017-18
    • Job Vacancies
  • News
    • Tallis Newsletters
    • BBC School Report 2018
    • Tallis Photography
    • Tallis Video
    • Tallis Sounds
  • Calendar
    • The School Day
    • Term Dates 2018-19
  • Curriculum
    • Curriculum Areas >
      • Business & ICT
      • Computing
      • English & Philosophy
      • Design & Technology
      • Humanities & Social Sciences
      • Mathematics
      • Modern Foreign Languages
      • Performing Arts
      • Physical Education
      • Science
      • Visual & Media Arts
    • Pastoral Care
    • Guidance
    • Key Stage 3 >
      • KS3 Assessment guidance
      • Tallis Choices
    • Key Stage 4
    • Tallis Post 16
    • More Able Learners
    • Special Educational Needs & Disabilities >
      • Learning Support Unit
      • Support Centre for Autism and Language Impairment
      • Deaf Support Centre
      • English as an Additional Language
    • Extra-Curricular Activities
  • Community
    • Letters Home
    • PTFA >
      • Supporting Thomas Tallis School
    • Governing Board
    • The Tallis Agreement
    • Admissions
    • Transition
    • Attendance & Punctuality
    • School Uniform
    • Policies & Guidelines >
      • Making Complaints
    • Support Your Teen
    • Online Safety
    • WisePay Payment Portal
    • Tallis Post 16
  • Students
    • Year 11 Support & Guidance
    • Independent Learning
    • Exam Revision
    • Stay Safe
    • Rewards
    • Reading
    • The Library
    • School Council
    • Cycling at Tallis
    • Alumni
  • Staff
  • Links
  • Contact
    • School Map
    • How to find us
  • Search